Active vs. Passive Real Estate Investing - Physician on FIRE (2024)

There are so many different ways to invest in real estate. I used to think of real estate investors as people who bought houses and condos and rented them out.

That’s just one example of active real estate investing, and there are dozens of ways to invest in real estate in very active ways, totally passive ways, and everything in between.

Dr. Peter Kim talks about the spectrum of opportunities and what to expect as you shift from hands-on investing to a hands-off approach or vice versa, and he discusses the benefits and pitfalls of the different approaches.

If you’d like to learn how to invest in passive real estate, especially in syndications and funds, join the waitlist for the upcoming launch of Dr. Kim’s Passive Real Estate Academy to receive exclusive freebies and discounts on his popular signature online course. This post originally appeared on Passive Income MD.

As you probably know, investing in real estate is my favorite way achieve financial freedom.

Part of what makes it interesting to me is how versatile real estate investing can be. It can be passive, something that provides ongoing returns without a lot of micromanaging. On the other hand, it can be quite active.

Now, I know what you’re thinking, Isn’t my blog called Passive Income MD? Isn’t the whole idea of investing to create passive income?

That’s a good point. Let’s think for a moment about what “passive income” really means. It’s income that is not proportional to the time you put into acquiring it. In very basic terms, it means that you’re not trading time for money, which is what most people do.

Almost no one is looking for an additional job, after all. If you’re like me, you need money to live and provide for your family, but you value time. And we all know that medicine isn’t getting any better in terms of the income/time ratio for physicians.

With real estate investing being such a huge industry with so many players and ways to get involved, you just have to find out which part of it will help you accomplish your goals. And since it’s so versatile, you can truly decide how much time, energy, and effort you want to put into it.

Active vs. Passive Real Estate Investing - Physician on FIRE (1)Learn how to better manage your student loan debt, and explore refinancing to a lower rate with cash back offers up to $1,000!Student Loan Resource Page

Active vs. Passive

The way I think about whether an investment is active or passive has to do with the amount of ongoing work is involved to maintain the investment.

There are some investment methods that I don’t mention much because they’re so extremely active (e.g., fix-and-flipping).

However, most people think of real estate investing as one or the other. Either it’s active or it’s passive. In reality, it’s more of a spectrum, with passive on one end and active on the other. For me, the dividing distinction between the two whether or not you’re a landlord.

To illustrate this concept, here’s a little chart that I’ve adapted from the White Coat Investor’s “Fire Your Financial Advisor” course.

Active vs. Passive Real Estate Investing - Physician on FIRE (2)

Active Investing

Active vs. Passive Real Estate Investing - Physician on FIRE (3)

Everything that involves being a landlord I put on the active side.

Owning rental property is definitely active if you’re self-managing. This means that you purchase rental property, lease it to tenants, and handle all of the property management issues like collecting rents and dealing with maintenance calls.

For the most part, I’m against self-managing. I think it’s better to outsource by finding good property management. Your time is better spent finding new opportunities, overseeing the operations of your portfolio, or simply spending time with your loved ones.

Now, if you do hire property management, your investment starts to swing toward the passive side. Once you identify the property you want to purchase, do the due diligence, and actually hire good management, you should only be getting calls for major issues.

Turnkey rental property companies try to make this process even easier for investors. They tend to identify good investment properties, often do the necessary renovations, find tenants, and provide property management. This moves you even further to the passive side.

Passive Investing

What’s in the passive real estate investing camp?

Active vs. Passive Real Estate Investing - Physician on FIRE (5)

What makes a real estate investment truly passive is not directly owning the property yourself. In these cases, you are definitely not the landlord.

Examples of investments like these include syndications, real estate funds, crowdfunding opportunities, and REITs.

Now, let’s spend a little time defining each of these a little more in-depth.

Syndications are essentially a pooling of funds to purchase a real estate investment. The company or people running the syndication (known as syndicators, operators, or sponsors) find a deal, put together the business plan, and raise money from investors to fund the deal. They then manage the deal and pay out investors according to the terms of the deal.

Syndications are different from real estate funds in that the asset or opportunity is already identified and money is being raised specifically for the asset.

With real estate funds, the fund operators raise money from investors, then use those funds to purchase different investments. Investors typically invest blindly, meaning that they trust that the fund operators will be able to follow their business plan. These funds typically purchase multiple properties.

If syndications are like individual stocks, real estate funds are like mutual funds, a collection of stocks. There are pros and cons to investing in each, all of which I’ve discussed in a previous post.

Crowdfunding is a term that really defines how investors get access to deals. Usually, the crowdfunded deals are found online, and they seek to raise money from investors. It typically allows them to pool or “fund from the crowd,” so that each investor is able to put down a smaller amount toward the investment. For example, my very first investment was in a crowdfunded deal, and I only had to put down $5,000.

REITs (Real Estate Investment Trusts) are companies that own income-producing real estate. They are in many ways similar to real estate funds, in that investors invest passively into these opportunities and the REIT operators manage and pay distributions to those investors. When someone invests in a REIT, it’s more like they’re purchasing a share of the company. Contrast that to a real estate fund, wherein they’re purchasing shares of the properties themselves.

These are all very general terms, but they get the point across.

Now that we have an idea of what’s out there, let’s take a look at some of the pros and cons of passive and active investing.

Active Investing: Pros and Cons

Pros

Control – When investing in a more active way, the investor has the most control of these investments. They can decide exactly how to run the investment, like whether they’d like to refinance or sell.

Taxes – Since the more active types of investment are usually directly owned, there are often more tax benefits provided to investors. They can decide how to take those tax benefits and use them to their benefit.

Cons

Experience – Active investments require a bit more knowledge on actual operations in order to be successful. The burden of knowledge rests on your shoulders, and you have more responsibility.

Time – The fact that it’s considered “active” means the work is slightly more ongoing, with more decisions having to be made by the investors. All of this adds up to a much higher time commitment.

Passive Investing: Pros and Cons

Pros

Time – It’s passive, meaning that most–if not all–of the work done by the investor is upfront. You choose which operator or sponsor to work with and what to invest their money in, and then you’re pretty much done.

Experience – Often, you don’t need a lot of experience because you’re leveraging the experience of the sponsors and operators. You’re letting the experts do what they do best.

Cons

Lack of control – Since you’re not completely in charge in this situation, you’re relying on management to make the best decisions for the project. They decide how to operate it, what rents to set, whether to refinance and ultimately when to sell.

Lack of liquidity – As the investor, you don’t have the ability to necessarily make the decision of when to sell. Because of this, it can be hard to get your money out if you need.

There are some exceptions to the rule, though. For example, some of these deals have provisions which allow for an exit in special circ*mstances and conditions, but you have to carefully read the PPM for that.

There are other specific types of investment that are more liquid than others, but generally, that money will be tied up for a while.

What Do Most Physicians Prefer?

Well, I did a recent poll in the Passive Income Docs Facebook group, and about 2/3 of physicians said they prefer the passive investments, while about 1/3 preferred active.

Many people feel they have to do one or the other. Personally, I do both. But lately, I’ve been investing slightly more into passive deals.

Passive investments can allow for the creation of cash flow. Over time, this can add up to significant sums that can help replace some or all of the income necessary to become financially free.

That’s always been the goal for me with the real investments I make; to ultimately replace my day job income so that I choose to work on my own terms.

When choosing an investment for yourself, it’s important to ask what you want out of it. Find a deal that matches your goals and go for it. It may be passive, it may be active, or it may be somewhere in between. As long as it gives you what you want, then that choice will almost always be the right one.

Active vs. Passive Real Estate Investing - Physician on FIRE (7)Active vs. Passive Real Estate Investing - Physician on FIRE (8)

My 5 Current and 3 Future Passive Income Streams

A 2023 Update on My Passive Real Estate Investment Returns

Use Amex Points to Get Up to $80 off Amazon Purchases for Prime Day
Active vs. Passive Real Estate Investing - Physician on FIRE (2024)

FAQs

Is it better to be an active or passive real estate investor? ›

When it comes to income, an active real estate investor stands to receive 100% of the profits by being the sole proprietor. An active investor commits their time and exposes themself to risk in return for a greater share of the rewards. On the flip side, passive investors split the profits among many parties.

Does passive investing outperform active investing? ›

Key Takeaways

Passive investment is less expensive, less complex, and often produces superior after-tax results over medium to long time horizons when compared to actively managed portfolios.

What is active vs passive investing for dummies? ›

Passive funds are generally better for beginners and retail investors looking for low-cost assets with decreased risk. Active funds are better for experienced, hands-on investors who have market knowledge and don't mind the high risk.

What are the disadvantages of passive investing? ›

Passive Investing Disadvantages

Small returns: By definition, passive funds will pretty much never beat the market, even during times of turmoil, as their core holdings are locked in to track the market.

What are the problems with passive investing? ›

The Danger of Passive Investing for Markets

That is, in a market downturn, there may be a rush for the exits as both passive and active investors get out of large cap stocks. This may become even more of an issue as passive funds continue to take market share from active peers.

Are target date funds passively or actively managed? ›

Key Takeaways

Target-date funds are actively managed and periodically restructured to gradually reduce risk as the target retirement date approaches. Target-date funds can be riskier than most people expect, but they usually become less volatile than individual stock market index funds as the target date approaches.

Why active funds are better than passive funds? ›

While active funds strive to outperform the market through skilled management and decision-making, passive funds offer a simpler, more consistent approach by tracking market indices. Ultimately, the choice between active and passive funds depends on individual preferences and objectives.

What is one disadvantage of the passive strategy? ›

Disadvantages: Limited Upside: By mirroring the market, passive investments will never outperform the index they track. No Downside Protection: During market downturns, passive strategies do not adjust to mitigate losses.

What's one of the biggest disadvantages of real estate as an investment? ›

Lack of Liquidity

It's easy to sell stocks if you need money or just want to cash out but that's not usually the case with real estate investments. You could end up selling below market or at a loss because of the lack of liquidity if you need to unload your property quickly.

Why active over passive investing? ›

“Active” Advantages

Among the benefits they see: Flexibility – because active managers, unlike passive ones, are not required to hold specific stocks or bonds. Hedging – the ability to use short sales, put options, and other strategies to insure against losses.

Can active investing beat the market? ›

Active strategies have tended to benefit investors more in certain investing climates, and passive strategies have tended to outperform in others. For example, when the market is volatile or the economy is weakening, active managers may outperform more often than when it is not.

Can you do both active and passive investing? ›

However, if you want to actively manage your investments and have the knowledge and time to do so, then active investing may be more suitable for you. Alternatively, you can also use a hybrid approach where you allocate a portion of your portfolio to passive investing and the rest to active investing.

What are the tax benefits of a passive investor? ›

Passive investors can take advantage of tax loss harvesting, a strategy to offset capital gains with capital losses. This can be done by selling lost value investments and using the losses to offset gains from other investments. This can help to reduce your overall tax bill and increase your after-tax returns.

How small investors are making passive income in real estate? ›

Investors who want to invest in real estate for passive income can look into real estate investment trusts (REITs), crowdfunding opportunities, remote ownership and real estate funds. These types of investments allow investors to generate real estate income without physical labor or the responsibilities of a landlord.

Is it better to be a real estate agent or investor? ›

Real estate agents earn commissions on their deals. This can vary from 1% to 5%, or sometimes even more, depending on the property. However, a real estate investor earns no commission; rather, the investor benefits from the difference between the purchase price and sale price of a property.

What is a passive investor in real estate? ›

In short, passive real estate investing means: Investing at a lower capital amount / barrier to entry (and “owning a piece” of the real estate transaction or project) Less involvement in the day-to-day management of the asset (perhaps none) Removing personal liability.

Top Articles
Before Giving to a Charity
Gifts and entertainment Definition | Law Insider
Davita Internet
Stadium Seats Near Me
Valley Fair Tickets Costco
Summit County Juvenile Court
Here are all the MTV VMA winners, even the awards they announced during the ads
Ashlyn Peaks Bio
Bluegabe Girlfriend
Bhad Bhabie Shares Footage Of Her Child's Father Beating Her Up, Wants Him To 'Get Help'
Needle Nose Peterbilt For Sale Craigslist
B67 Bus Time
[PDF] INFORMATION BROCHURE - Free Download PDF
Koop hier ‘verloren pakketten’, een nieuwe Italiaanse zaak en dit wil je ook even weten - indebuurt Utrecht
Belly Dump Trailers For Sale On Craigslist
Amc Flight Schedule
Water Days For Modesto Ca
Ups Access Point Lockers
Classic | Cyclone RakeAmerica's #1 Lawn and Leaf Vacuum
Blue Rain Lubbock
Tripadvisor Napa Restaurants
Www.craigslist.com Savannah Ga
Craigslist Northfield Vt
Miltank Gamepress
What Are The Symptoms Of A Bad Solenoid Pack E4od?
Craigslist Dubuque Iowa Pets
Page 2383 – Christianity Today
Xxn Abbreviation List 2017 Pdf
Smartfind Express Login Broward
'Insidious: The Red Door': Release Date, Cast, Trailer, and What to Expect
208000 Yen To Usd
Bridgestone Tire Dealer Near Me
Vip Lounge Odu
Swimgs Yuzzle Wuzzle Yups Wits Sadie Plant Tune 3 Tabs Winnie The Pooh Halloween Bob The Builder Christmas Autumns Cow Dog Pig Tim Cook’s Birthday Buff Work It Out Wombats Pineview Playtime Chronicles Day Of The Dead The Alpha Baa Baa Twinkle
Amici Pizza Los Alamitos
Tal 3L Zeus Replacement Lid
AI-Powered Free Online Flashcards for Studying | Kahoot!
Case Funeral Home Obituaries
Msnl Seeds
The Vélodrome d'Hiver (Vél d'Hiv) Roundup
Cal Poly 2027 College Confidential
R/Moissanite
Silive Obituary
Weekly Math Review Q2 7 Answer Key
Tlc Africa Deaths 2021
Kjccc Sports
Underground Weather Tropical
17 of the best things to do in Bozeman, Montana
Superecchll
211475039
ats: MODIFIED PETERBILT 389 [1.31.X] v update auf 1.48 Trucks Mod für American Truck Simulator
Selly Medaline
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Margart Wisoky

Last Updated:

Views: 5599

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (58 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Margart Wisoky

Birthday: 1993-05-13

Address: 2113 Abernathy Knoll, New Tamerafurt, CT 66893-2169

Phone: +25815234346805

Job: Central Developer

Hobby: Machining, Pottery, Rafting, Cosplaying, Jogging, Taekwondo, Scouting

Introduction: My name is Margart Wisoky, I am a gorgeous, shiny, successful, beautiful, adventurous, excited, pleasant person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.